UN Monitoring Group, politics of "Good Governance"
- Posted on Thursday 2 August 2012 - 11:00By Abukar ArmanSince its inception, the UN Monitoring Group on Somalia (and Eritrea) has been rolling over controversies, mainly in its reporting, sourcing, and unsubstantiated claims. I just got through reading its latest report made of truths, half-truths, and a whole lot of innuendoes that implicate at least four present/past officials and presidential candidates with certain level of skepticism.
This is not to deny or dismiss any accusations made against anyone in the report for I neither have the facts to prove nor disprove their actions or inactions. It is to simply practice the fundamentals. In politics a moderate dose of skepticism is a healthy requisite that only the gullible can afford to ignore; especially when the entity in question has a record in political myth-making.
In its 2007 report, the Monitoring Group made two outlandish claims which were clearly orchestrated to pave the way for Ethiopia’s invasion and occupation of Somalia. They claimed that al-Shabaab (Sunni extremists) has exported 720 of its militant fighters to help Hizbullah (Shi’i nationalists) of Lebanon in its fight against Israel, and that Iranian scientists were mining uranium for their nuclear program in Dhuso Mareeb.
This wild claim, which was a page out of the Iraq war playbook, has earned Ethiopia the International Community that it needed to fund and sustain that failed project. You may read more on ‘The Making of Another Iraq.’
Interestingly, this latest report comes out only a few weeks before Somalia was to emerge out of a long transitional period on August 20th, and due to its broad media coverage, it ends up dominating the political discourse. Much of the report is insightful and apolitical while the rest is clearly used for political reasons or simply as a red herring.
The central questions dominating the political discourse are no longer: Why are certain elements within the International Community is forcing a controversial new constitution on the Somali people? What specific geographical boundaries of the new constitution? Would the new government be able to fully claim its sovereignty? Would it be able to claim its national assets in various Western banks? And would it have the right to demand the UN agencies and varies NGOs who are members of the Ghost-lords network to open their books and report publicly how they have been handling roughly around $1 billion aid money to Somalia per year? It is about $130 million that the Monitoring Group claims has not been accounted for or may have been misappropriated by officials in various transitional governments since 2000. Make no mistake, these are very serious revelations in this report that if proven accurate ought to be grounds for prosecution.
Indeed, “kleptocracy” and institutionalized corruption is still alive though there is snail-pace progress toward improvement. Decades since independence, before any institutions of checks and balances could be built, clans would and continue to compete on who should have the exclusive rights to this ministry or that. The driving assumption almost always being if an individual from one’s clan were to be granted that exclusive right he or she would favor individuals from his or her own clan by way of nepotism.
While exploiting that inherently unflattering reputation coupled with the successive status of being rated the most failed state, the Monitoring Group uses two different yard sticks for ascertaining allegations.
A case in point, the Monitoring Group exonerates Eritrea against allegations of illegally arming al-Shabaab with shipments of weapons despite multiple testimonies and reports from, according to the report, government officials, “an intelligence report from a military source”, “an international organization with contacts on the ground,” and the Kenyan government. Despite all these, the report concludes “The Monitoring Group received no credible reports or evidence of assistance from Eritrea to armed opposition groups in Somalia during the course of the mandate.”
On the other hand, the report directly condemns various members of the current and previous transitional governments based on claims made by two disgruntled employees who were both (for the right or wrong reasons) sacked disgracefully. Should such information not be relevant? And what was their attitude before they got the urge to go public with their seemingly not-so-divinely-inspired claims? I suppose only when they support foregone conclusions.
When it comes to incriminating or condemning people based on unsubstantiated individual testimonies or that of an entity, credibility should be the determining factor. Therefore, it is utterly reprehensible for the Monitoring Group to recommend the Security Council to take punitive actions against these accused officials.
Weeding out corrupt officials out of the political system is in the best interest of Somalia, but it is a matter that Somalia can investigate and pursue on its own. If the fast approaching end of the transitional period means Somalia would be able to claim its lost sovereignty and be given enough room to handle its own affairs, then the new parliament and government should deal with this matter.
Meanwhile, if this is about the promotion of good governance and the protection of revenues and donated funds, the Monitoring Group should consider urging the Security Council to demand the Ghost-lords and all UN agencies that are tasked to provide services to Somalia to open their books and list any and all tangible projects that they have completed in Somalia.
Coincidently, the report has nothing to say about the laboratory of international corruption in Nairobi that profoundly hinders any significant progress in Somalia. It says nothing about the almost $1 billion per year squandered in Nairobi that the Transitional Federal Government has no say or knowledge as to how, when, and where it is spent.
It is interesting how the allegations in the report are solely based on monies collected or promised the government on bilateral bases. It is even more interesting how these crocodile tears against corruption started immediately after officials within the TFG requested all UN agencies to open their books and to hire an independent firm to conduct general audit and administer forensic accounting to reclaim Somalia’s assets in various Western banks.
It is about time the Security Council reconsiders the absolute power it granted to the Monitoring Group. It is about time to “police the police” or monitor the Monitoring Group since they have full immunity from any law suits for lies that they occasionally propagate, not to mention defamation and character assassinations. It is about time that the Security Council protects the integrity of that august institution.
Abukar Arman is Somalia Special Envoy to the United States and a widely published political analyst
Reactions
- Posted on Saturday 12 January 2013 12:54At windSpeed we can help you handle the stress of looking for a decent hotel to Lodge in.We are the best when it comes to Hotel Booking and Reservation in Lagos Nigeria. Contact Us Now on Email,
Wsbnig@gmail.com , Tel: (+234) 08187976604, 07083411981 - Posted on Monday 01 April 2013 08:597Advice To Plan The Very Best Wedding party At any time
Many individuals would say that relationship is amongst the most significant daily life techniques a person will experience. Sadly, arranging a wedding event can occasionally become a challenging and strenuous occasion to organize. The fee for wedding parties and strong preparing can anxiety the calmest of men and women. This short article contains suggestions and ideas to help you prepare a lovely wedding effortlessly.
If you fear that individuals won't want to provide you with cash wedding event gifts since they don't have a lot of money to provide, add a "funds box" with the front door in your wedding party. Company are inquired inside the traditional invitations to create their gift Gucci Scarpe in a unmarked envelope, permit them to place it within the pack anonymously and Broncos Welker Jersey Womens decreasing any a sense of guilt they might truly feel.
Set individuals in your wedding together in furniture of people who have similar likes and dislikes, interests, or jobs. That will allow them to have some thing to speak about whilst they appreciate their meal in the wedding party, and lowers any difficult emotions for the company. You would like the day being perfect and special for everyone in attendance!
Speak to your family and friends with regards to services to your wedding. You Borsa Gucci will never know when you may have an ignored general who deals with audio or food preparation. You can even find that your friends have connections to support experts who can offer you a discounted price because of the referral.
Wedding parties are likely to bring about a variety of feelings with the family and buddies. It really is quickest that you should simply independent your wedding event organization from your personalized lifestyle instead of allowing it to get in the way of your daily life and causing trouble. Independent the wedding ceremony particulars and you may be on your way to a significantly significantly less anxious wedding prep phase.
General online windows registry providers allow couples to add items to their registries from practically any on-line merchant. This really is a great way to make purchasing gift items handy for your loved ones family and friends are able to use their favored charge cards Nike Air Max to help make transactions, take advantage of on-line special offers, and retail outlet for the best price ranges.
Wait around before making major wedding party selections. When you visit see a location that you are currently sure you like, don't placed down a downpayment right away. Go house, look at several other places, and create a selection then. Creating impulse choices may cost you more cash along with a life time of regret so be sure you think around you are able to.
Provide a swatch of materials from your wedding gown along with you once you purchase your footwear. This will help to complement the shades or find a coordinating color, if that is what you decide to do. There are so many different versions of bright white when you only choose bright white footwear, you're likely to have it completely wrong. Using a swatch will help you make the correct choice.
As was reviewed at the outset of this short article, a wedding event is really a momentous occasion, but is ridden with various choices and expenses. Preventing the strain related to preparation marriage ceremonies can be difficult for several. Apply the recommendations Monster Beats Pas Cher with this report and you will definitely be moving toward planning for a excellent wedding event. - Posted on Wednesday 10 April 2013 10:31If needed you can request any of your pals or relative who are also putting on these swiss replica watches. But are you currently positive which you can be in a placement to recognize them, instead their omega replica watches? As everybody knows, this Swiss rolex replica watches on the net are pretty difficult to create out from your actual also it may properly be that the buddy is putting on the actual one.
- Posted on Friday 31 May 2013 07:431st lets investigate the Hublot blowup Tourbillon, associate fully rolex datejust replica spectacular duplicate that friends/colleagues area unit unable to differentiate vs. the important deal. The motion is attractive, no faults that I will see breitling replica within the fabrication aside from a pair of minor flaws…1) I detected the opposite day that the date solely modified half-way (basically it didn’t go so much enough and it absolutely was already 9am)…easily christian louboutin salecorrected and hasn’t happened once more.
Second minor flaw is missing white paint replica watches uk (very little) on the face of the watch wherever it says restricted breitling replica edition…overall, more than happy with duplicate and carrying it daily! Replica#2 was a Breitling Transoceaner…this duplicate is FLAWLESS…absolutely attractive, runs while not problems omega replica (Quartz movement though) and also the weight feels right…I’m therefore proud of this watch!
The #3 was {a duplicate|a reproduction|a duplicate} Rolex Submariner…probably the foremost obvious replica of the bunch because of a but excellent “Rolex” movement…obviously for $155 you’re not planning to get the right swish movement though! Overall the watch is incredibly nice and runs well! - Posted on Thursday 06 June 2013 08:24The History Of Shoes ut excellent “Rolex” movement…obviously for $155 you’re not planning to get the right swish movement though! Overall the watch is incredibly nice and ru
- Posted on Thursday 06 June 2013 16:30Replica Designer Handbags
are of many types. For instance, these bags are available in different shapes, sizes and quality. They are available on sale in huge numbers both online as well as offline. Discount Replica Gucci Handbags
_footer
Home | About us | Contact | RSS | Services | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy
Copyright Africa Interactive 2013 | mail@africanews.com
Powered by React - www.react.nl
