Row over Mandela heritage museum


  1. Mtheto Lungu, AfricaNews reporter in Lilongwe, Malawi
    A museum built to honour the legacy of Nelson Mandela is turning into a national embarrassment forcing Cameron Dugmore, former Western Cape education minister, to vow to raise his concerns about the heritage site with the premier of the Eastern Cape.
    WC 2010-Mandela to decide his attendence on the day
    Dugmore visited the site last Sunday and was left standing alone in an open-air museum without a guide.

    As if that is not enough, Mandela's grandson, Mandla, this week criticised museum management of undermining the Madiba legacy. The official museum tour excludes Mandela's birthplace, Mvezo.

    The museum's management, however, denies any wrongdoing. They claim instead the museum is becoming increasingly popular - to the point where it is in fact battling to cope with the large number of visitors.

    Facebook

    Dugmore prompted a flurry of comments on the internet after writing about his museum experience on Facebook.

    "I was with family on the way to Durban. My daughters had read books about Nelson Mandela's early years and we wanted them to see the museum. There was supposed to be a multimedia centre - but there was a really arbitrary video playing there. No guide at all," he told the Sunday Times.

    "I did not see any other visitors when we arrived at about noon. I saw a vehicle arrive when we were leaving. 'It is an issue worth following up," Dugmore said.

    Mandla Mandela said the museum was a "white elephant" that had alienated itself from the local Qunu community, as well as from the nearby Mvezo community where Mandela was born.

    He said the museum had declined to collaborate with the Mandela family on heritage matters.

    "They don't work with Mvezo anymore. They have totally omitted Mvezo from their books. We have continuously come to their (museum) offices and asked for a relationship, because of the name that we hold of the family. But they have showed no interest, so we have also given up.

    "Hopefully one day they will see the light and realise that there is a keenness on the part of the community of Mvezo to work together," Mandela said.

    He said the local Qunu chief was snubbed by museum officials who did not invite him to an official museum function involving the former minister of arts and culture, Lulu Xingwana.

    "There wasn't a single person from Qunu. The community was not even informed about the function. I think they lack the collectiveness approach that was embraced by my grandfather," Mandela said.

    Spokesperson for the Museum, Nokuzola Tetani, denied excluding the Mandela clan and said the institution continued to take visitors on tours of Mvezo.

    Increase in visitors

    She said a recent increase in visitor numbers meant there was sometimes a shortage of guides at the main museum complex: "There is an increase in demand for visiting the other sites directly associated with Mandela.

    "That may be the problem that we did not foresee."

    She said the museum worked closely with the community, and with members of Mandela's family.

    "Our guides do take visitors to Mvezo. We have not encountered any problems so far."

    According to the museum's website, however, Mvezo is excluded as part of the official museum tour.

    "Mvezo is not currently operated by the museum," the website says.

    Officially opened by Nelson Mandela 10 years after his release from jail, the Nelson Mandela Museum operates semi-independently, but receives a government grant.

    It has two main sites: the open-air Nelson Mandela Youth & Heritage Centre in Qunu, and the Bhunga Building in Mthatha.

    In addition to the open-air museum outside Qunu, visitors are escorted around several Mandela sites, including the family graveyard, historical buildings and a large flat granite stone where the young Madiba used to play.

    Nelson Mandela Foundation spokesman Sello Hatang said the institution was not involved in museum affairs.

    The Department of Arts and Culture - a partner in running the museum - could not be reached for comment this week.



Latest News

  1. OPINION: Welcome to African Green Revolution24/05For the past century and a half, Africa has tried various agricultural approaches without much success.
  2. Egyptians vote in historic election23/05Egyptians began voting freely on Wednesday for the first time to pick their president in a wide open election that pits Islamists against men who serv…
  3. Africa Day 2012 - a moment for reflection and…22/0525th May is Africa Day. For many years it has been a celebration of African unity. It dates back to 1963 when the Organisation of African Unity (OAU) …
  4. South Africa's African agenda21/05The Deputy President of the Republic of South Africa, Kgalema Mothlanthe paid a rare visit to Ghana in April at the invitation of John Dramani Mahama …
  5. Women struggle to rinse hunger, poverty stains21/05Just looking at her one clearly appreciates that she is old and frail therefore in need of support for food, clothing and shelter to live comfortably …
  6. Climate Climate change affects migratory birds…21/05Changes in the climate globally have affected the movement of both migratory and resident species of birds, Nature Uganda has said.
  7. Ghana: Foreign retailers cited for currency…18/05The Ghana Union of Traders Association (GUTA) is attributing the sharp depreciation of the Ghana cedi against major currencies to the illegal activiti…
  8. Kenya: Community radio brings succour to…18/05Korogocho, a slum in northeastern Nairobi with 100,000 inhabitants, had many of the ingredients for a political explosion similar to those that rocked…
  9. Veld fires 'flame' Zimbabwe's…16/05Over the years, Zimbabwe has experienced the scourge of veld fires destroying property worth thousands of dollars.
  10. Liberia commends ECOWAS for support14/05The induction training of pioneer Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) Volunteers for Liberia kicked off in Monrovia, with the Deputy Mi…
  11. Vanishing Lake Chad puts 30m lives at risk14/05As you approach the Lake Chad basin from Maiduguri, in north-eastern Nigeria, the evidence of despair is telling.
  12. Heavy rains cause havoc in Kenya14/05Heavy Rainfall continued to wreak havoc across the country leading to the suspension of relief food in some parts of the country as most roads in Turk…
  13. Zimbabwe: Growth points lie dormant14/05The Zimbabwean government mooted the concept of growth points in the 1980s as a means of decongesting cities and towns.
  14. Sierra Leone improves in infant mortality11/05Sierra Leone has improved in infant mortality cases according to Save the Children- World Motherhood index 2012 report. The West Africa country descri…
  15. Zimbabwe: Resettled farmers fail to utilize…10/05Resettled farmers in Zimbabwe are failing to utilize land due to inadequate farming inputs and lack of resources.
News archive