Kenya: Tribunal to try violence suspects


  1. Maina Waruru, AfricaNews reporter in Nairobi, Kenya Photo: Larmeck Nyagudi. During the post-election riot
    Kenya has resolved to set up a local tribunal to try suspects implicated in the 2008 post election violence that killed more than 1000 people and saw some 350,000 others displaced from their homes.
    Lameck Nyagudi riots in the streets of kenya
    The decision by the country’s parliament comes in the wake of findings of a commission appointed to unearth those who financed, planned, organized or incited that violence - the worst in the East African country’s history that emanated from the disputed presidential poll.

    The findings of the commission chaired by a local high court judge Philip Waki, contain a list of 10 prominent persons among them six cabinet ministers cited for investigation and prosecution for alleged crimes against humanity.

    The list is in custody of former UN secretary general Kofi Anan - the man who presided over peace talks in the country that resulted in the formation of a coalition government between President Mwai Kibaki and his main rival in the disputed poll, prime minister Raila Odinga .

    The Annan mediation team that included former South African first lady Graca Machel, gave the Kenyan parliament up to 31st of March to constitute a local tribunal failure to which the list of the suspects will be handed over to the International Criminal Court (ICC) in the Hague for prosecution.

    The parliament this week made its first step toward establishing the tribunal, enacting a law that will pave way for appointment of four local and foreign judges to preside over prosecution of suspects, but made a provision to save political careers of those named in the list.

    While Annan had recommended that those named in the list will quit public offices once the panel of judges is in place, the parliament altered that clause to have the suspects only step down once an international prosecutor yet to be named establishes that an individual has a case to answer.

    This in effect means that ministers in the list and all of whom are influential and powerful in the government will get some breathing space - they will keep their jobs until they are indicted and also probably use their office and money to manipulate witness and conceal evidence to avoid prosecution.

    Retaliatory meetings

    For example deputy prime minister and finance minister Uhuru Kenyatta , a confidant of president Kibaki and who is alleged to have sat in a meeting that planned retaliatory killings of non-Kikuyu communities in the rift valley province may escape indictment owing to the very secretive nature of such a meeting.

    The meeting if indeed took place is alleged to have been held in state house, president Kibaki’s official residence, and as such getting witnesses to give evidence against Kenyatta will never be easy.

    Other ministers named include William Ruto, William Ole Ntimama and Henry Kosgey all allied to Ondinga’s ODM party. Those found guilty will be barred from ever seeking and holding public office - elective or otherwise besides the court’s punishment.

    But fears are abound that certain legal technicalities in the laws of Kenya may be used to save such persons from punishment or even standing trial. For example under Kenyan laws the attorney general who is the government’s principal legal officer has the powers to terminate any criminal prosecutions any time he deems fit irrespective of crimes committed and without giving reasons.

    The Kenyan attorney general has in the past entered nolle proseque in numerous cases the most recent being in 2006 when he terminated a case filed by a local reporter against first lady Lucy Kibaki for assault.

    Secondly, the president has the powers to grant clemency to citizens legally jailed by courts without any reference to anyone and without giving reasons and irrespective of the gravity of crime committed.

    It is thus feared that unless the two laws are amended the president and the attorney general could use these powers watering down the effectiveness of the court. It is for this reasons that civil society groups here are calling for repeal of these clauses to ensure that those under trial do not escape justice.

    New law

    Another cause of concern is that the Kenyan parliament is on the verge of passing a new law called the Truth Justice and Reconciliation (TRJ) Act 2008, that calls for establishment of Truth and Reconciliation commission to deal with crimes committed against the public since the country’s independence from Britain in 1963.

    Under this act those named can confess their sins and seek forgiveness and be pardoned. As such they would escape punishment and get on with their lives.

    It is this act also that it is feared people who committed heinous crimes against humanity may use to go scot free denying justice to victims of their acts.

    But some people have argued that under international law the principle of pardon does not apply and the Kenyan tribunal will be set up precisely under this law.

    Aside from the law there is the political side of this whole business in that the persons named are powerful politicians close to both Kibaki and Raila and very central to their masters political lives.

    For example Kenyatta is Kibaki’s heir apparent in Kenya’s succession plan. It is therefore common sense that the president would do anything within his means to save his favorite heir and that may include manipulating the tribunal at every stage. He will ensure that the judges he appoints are weak- kneed yes guys who will do his binding.

    When all is said and done Kenyans can only wait and pray that justice will be done and that expediency will not stand in way of justice for the over 1000 victims and thousands who lost property in the violence.



Latest News

  1. AFCON: 46 hurt in Zambia victory celebrations09/02Over 40 casualty cases were recorded Wednesday night at Zambia's University Teaching Hospital (UTH) after post-match celebrations turned violent …
  2. African Peer Review Mechanism making progress08/02In 2003 the New Partnership for Africa's Development (NEPAD), the continental development plan, initiated the African Peer Review Mechanism (APRM…
  3. Combating HIV infections among African women08/02With a lack of knowledge and power, African women continue to bear the brunt of HIV infections.
  4. Legume cultivation booms in Western Kenya07/02Small Holder Farmers (SHFs) who traditionally relied on seed companies for all their seeds are now bulking their own legume seeds for their farms.
  5. Malawi vendors chase out Chinese07/02Vendors in Kalonga, the Northern district of Malawi, on Wednesday petitioned the District Commissioner to flash out all Chinese nationals who are doin…
  6. Zim: Informal sector urged to join HIV battle05/02While the Harare City council is busy engaging in running battles with city vendors, Health Minister has called for authorities to devise ways to form…
  7. Elections: Wole Soyinka warns Mugabe, Wade03/02The Nigerian Nobel Prize winner for literature said heads of states who are trying to cling to power suffer the same fate as the dictators who were sw…
  8. AU elections rescheduled for June in Malawi01/02Following a deadlock during Monday's African Union elections, with a tie between former wife to South African president Jacob Zuma, Home Affairs …
  9. Senegal in turmoil as protest intensifies01/02Hundreds of anti-government protesters Tuesday gathered in the central Dakar, Senegal to show their dissatisfaction over the incumbent president Abdou…
  10. Zimbabwe’s inflation still favourable -…01/02Zimbabwe's annual headline inflation still compared favourably with economies in the region, Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe Governor Gideon Gono said o…
  11. AFCON 2012: Sudan qualifies after four decades31/01The Sudanese national team has sealed a historic win over the Stallions of Burkina Faso.
  12. Senegalese opposition to intensify protests31/01Opposition and civil society groups in Senegal have vowed to increase their fight against incumbent President Abdoulaye Wade's presidential bid.
  13. Malawi: Rights coalition condemn stripping of…30/01The 39 members of the Solidarity for African Women's Rights Coalition based in 18 African countries have vehemently condemned the stripping of wo…
  14. Kenya to deworm five million children annually30/01Kenya launched the second phase of its national deworming programme at the World Economic Forum Annual Meeting 2012, aiming to treat 5 million childre…
  15. Benin’s Yayi Boni is AU’s new…30/01President Yayi Boni of Benin Republic has been elected chairperson of the African Union in the Ethiopian capital Addis Ababa
News archive